Had a reservation for 2. My date and I were running 15 minutes late so we called ahead of time and they still honored our reservation. Was seated upstairs in a nice private booth. Drinks were good. The waiter Pablo was exceptionally polite and was frequently checking in on us. Ordered bbq oysters and clams for appetizers. Both were tremendous. My date had the ahi tuna plate and I had the surf and turf. Both were extremely delicious and the flavors were off the chart. 10/10 would return.

This place is always amazing. We walked in and welcomed by the owner. They put us in a window booth overlooking the water. Ricardo greeted us and offered his recommendations upon request. I ordered the Captains Plate substituting the veggies for their Maple Sweet Potatoes. I highly recommend those. My wife ordered the large bowl of chowder which is the best we've ever had and too much for her to eat. We took the rest home for a whole another meal. Ricardo and Luis were all quick with drink refills. I cannot recommend this place enough . Even though they didn't know it was 35th wedding anniversary, they still managed to impress with great food and equally as great service. Thank you.

Excellent, prompt service. Giovanny and a gentleman the manager made the experience a memorable one. My wife and I got the cup of clam chowder + half shrimp salad sandwich and it was amazing. It was busy and yet had a very pleasant ambiance. We'll definitely be back

We got crab cakes, chicken parmesean, the cod tacos, and the butterscotch bread pudding. Everything was cooked so well and absolutely delicious. I was actually startled when I took my first bite of the pudding, it was that good. I wish i got the shrimp instead of cod for my taco, but I think thats personal taste. The restaurant itself overlooked the water and was cozy inside.
There was a pretty big issue with one of our dishes, but our waitress Janette handled it so gracefully. We will definitely be back

We were so impressed by everything about this restaurant we did something we never do and ate here two nights running. Service was so slick and well organised and the food was top notch. Great ambiance with lighting and music just right. The owner goes round and introduces himself to the guests whilst keeping an eye on all the employees which maybe explains why this operation runs like clockwork. A real classy establishment and highly recommended.

The food was incredible! The clam chowder was tasty. We had a grilled artichoke that was also delicious. We also tried the calamari eggplant Parmesan. The calamari steak was very tender and it was large so easy to share between two people. The staff were considerate and service was excellent.

Second time , still very good and amazing service , has the fish and chips and the portion was huge . Clam Chowder was amazing and they give you a big bowl for the price .

My brother and I ate there earlier this week after a round of golf. We were welcomed the minute we sat down when the staff thanked my brother for his military service. They went above and beyond. The food was absolutely wonderful - the fish and chips and the lobster tail was fabulous and the service was equally special. Thank you for making our night so special.

I was Blessed and Very Fortunate to have the BEST 65th Dinner EVER at Old Fisherman's Grotto. We were seated at a window over the Bay which made for the Perfect Ambiance. Our service PABLO did an Excellent Job ensuring our experience was extra Special. Thank You Pablo for your Dynamic Service. The Clam Chowder and Calamari were without a doubt the Best I've ever had. The chowder was flavorful and filling, and the Calamari was light, fluffy and a little crunchy. Yummy!! I originally came for the Clam Chowder Bowl until I saw the Seafood Pasta which was Scrumptious. I was pleasantly Surprised to see a whole Lobster tail on the pasta. My husband had the plank Salmon which he Enjoyed. The complimentary Birthday Cheesecake and Rose were a Unique touch. We left Full and Satisfied. The prices were reasonable and I'd Highly recommend the Old Fisherman Grotto for anyone looking for a Delicious meal. You won't be disappointed.