We were just strolling on the pier after checking into the Portola Hotel and it got late so we figured we would find a place to eat on the pier. We are so glad we stopped here as it was such a beautiful experience. It was like a true old school Italian Style or Rat Pack era style restaurant. The service was amazing starting from the outside host to the waiters and bus boys. If prices are an issue for you than go inland because the piers prices are all expensive. Anyway, we had pasta and chicken Parmigiana, rib eye steak with asparagus and double baked potato, sampler appetizer and a bowl of clam chowder. Every thing was delicious! Streak was perfect medium rare and most importantly the service was excellent. They had plenty to staff. I loved the dim lighting and Big Band Era style music. Reminded me of my grandparents. I would definitely come again, especially on a date or with a group of friends or adult family. Between the service and quality of food I didn’t care about anything else.

Absolutely amazing experience. Right when we walked in we were taken care of and greeted like a family friend. Austin, the manager took us to a beautiful ocean view table and started the wonderful experience right away. The service was outstanding, Miguel really nailed it. The clam chowder really was THE best. The lobster and the risotto were top tier. Next time we're in town this will be our first stop. You must try it!

The reason I drive 6 hours often I can

Ordered clam chowder and a roll of bread. Fried calamari only. To go. Was about $50. It's a good treat every so often. Consistently good quality on these two items. If you eat inside women receive a rose.

We had such a great dinner at Old Fisherman's Grotto. The Oysters Rockefeller were rich and delicious, and the warm goat cheese and beet salad was honestly one of my favorite bites of the night. For mains, the cioppino was packed with fresh seafood and so comforting, while the halibut with prawns was tender, flavorful, and beautifully presented.

The whole evening just felt nice, good food, warm service, and that classic Monterey Wharf atmosphere that makes you slow down and enjoy the moment. We left happy, full, and already talking about coming back.

The food was absolutely amazing! The ambiance is so romantic. The server was so attentive and helpful with the menu. Celebrating my birthday!

One of the best food experiences we have ever had. Wonderful food, great service, and old school ambiance. We have never been here before and we're traveling to the Monterey area and has to try out this place. We definitely will be back!! The manager on duty was extremely accommodating and very helpful. We loved everything we ordered.

Luis was our service person. He was very nice and recommended the local offerings of the day. He had mentioned that bottles of wine were on special, and we do not drink. I asked about military discounts instead cans he said that was not available at this time. I was honestly just asking, because the wine was on special to be sassy. Luis came back with an amazing appetizer for us to share.
Shocked and amazed. But swiped grateful... and he didn't with a smile.
The food was fantastic and hit the spot. Coconut shrimp with the mango sauce was GREAT. Totally hit the spot!
To end our dinner, he offered my husband a dessert on the house for his military service. How sweet was that! Totally unexpected! This is quite an honor.
Really good service and great food. Service with a smile and just over all great customer service.
I would totally rate this place more than the 5 star limit.
Impeccable and super wonderful experience.

Food was delicious and service was excellent! We have been here numerous times and it never disappoints.